What does an early case assessment cover?
Early case assessment is a short, structured look at a matter near the start. The aim is to decide whether and how to proceed, and to set expectations with the client.
| Question | Where the answer comes from | Where AI can help |
|---|---|---|
| What happened? | Client account and documents | Order facts into a timeline |
| What are the legal issues? | Your analysis of the law | Suggest issues to consider, which you verify |
| What evidence exists? | Evidence list and requests | Flag what is missing |
| What are the risks? | Your judgement | Argue the other side's case for you to answer |
| What will it cost and take? | Your experience and fee model | Draft an estimate structure for you to complete |
How do you run one with an assistant?
- 1
Complete the matter record
Fill in parties, dates, claims and the evidence list before you ask anything.
- 2
Ask for a neutral summary
Have the assistant restate the facts and note inconsistencies.
- 3
Ask for gaps and risks
Request missing evidence, weak points and the other side's likely arguments.
- 4
Check the law yourself
Research the issues in authoritative sources, not from the assistant's memory.
- 5
Write your assessment
Record your view, the options and the next steps on the matter.
What to keep out of the assistant's hands
- The merits conclusion and any prediction of outcome.
- Case valuation and settlement ranges.
- Limitation and deadline calculations, which come from the rules.
- Anything you have not checked against a source.
Models tend to sound more certain than the facts allow. If the output reads as confident about a contested point, treat that as a prompt to investigate, not as an answer.
Frequently asked questions
- What is early case assessment?
- A structured review near the start of a matter to decide whether and how to proceed, based on the facts, issues, evidence, risks and expected cost.
- Can AI assess my case?
- It can help organise facts and surface gaps and counter-arguments, but it cannot reliably judge merits or value. That is the lawyer's decision.
- How should I record the assessment?
- Add a dated note to the matter with your conclusions, assumptions and chosen next steps, so you can compare later.
- Does MatterOS do early case assessment?
- It gives you a structured matter record and an AI prompt pack to support the process. The assessment itself is your professional work.
About the author
Raghav Handa trained as a lawyer, then spent years building legal technology, from enterprise legal products to custom systems for law firms.
Keep reading
- AILegal research with AI: a verification-first guideHow to use AI for legal research safely: scope the question, use it to find leads, verify every authority in a primary source and log what you found.3 min read · 17 October 2026
- GuidesThe living matter file: from static folder to working recordWhat a living matter file is, how it differs from a folder of documents, and how to build one in Notion with status, next step, linked actions, evidence and notes.3 min read · 17 October 2026
- GuidesClient intake checklist for small law firmsA client intake checklist you can adapt: contact and party details, conflict check, scope, fees, documents and first deadlines, plus how to keep it in Notion.3 min read · 17 October 2026
- AIAI for small law firms: why structure comes before toolsWhy AI disappoints small law firms without structured matters, how to make your practice AI-ready, safe first uses, confidentiality rules and human review.3 min read · 17 October 2026